Tuesday, January 20, 2015

Book Club A Go-Go

Three years have managed to slip past me. Seriously pathetic if you ask me. Anyway, to make up for my lack of posts, I shall give you my thoughts on the classic book "1984" by George Orwell. It's the first review of many to come. In an effort to broaden our minds, my cousin and I decided to start a book club (of two) and read all of the classics. It's only been a few years in the making. Please keep in mind that these questions are addressed to my cousin, so there will be references for her that will be unknown to you, as well as having an informal tone. So, without further ado, here you go:

Book Club Questions for 1984 (George Orwell)

1. How did you experience the book? Were you engaged immediately, or did it take you a while to "get into it"? How did you feel reading it—amused, sad, disturbed, confused, bored...?

I never really got into this book while I was reading it. I found the characters to be boring, and quite annoying. The concept of the story I found intriguing, and quite terrifying. It’s difficult to explain how I was bored with a story on one level, yet slightly disturbed on another. I found a lot of the content to be useless ramblings of descriptions I didn’t need / want.

2. Describe the main characters—personality traits, motivations, inner qualities.

Winston was a selfish, disgusting nitwit. While he was quite brilliant on seeing “through” big brother, he was an idiot when it came down to life in general. I found his behavior to be erratic and grossly inhumane, not to mention piggish. Julia reminds me of a preacher’s daughter. A child who rebels at every turn, and fights against authority just because. She had no real motivation, or cause.

• Why do characters do what they do?

Granted, being raised in an environment that dictates and watches your every move would cause mental instability, but I find the lack of compassion and humanity in this book to be concerning.

• Are their actions justified?

I don’t believe that any of Winston’s actions were justified. I think he was selfish, and couldn’t see past his own wants / needs. Nor do I believe that Julia’s actions were justified. Nothing in their actions were noteworthy toward any cause, although I will admit that they were never really given a chance to make a difference one way, or another.

• Describe the dynamics between characters (in a marriage, family, or friendship).

Winston and Julia were both using one another. Her to rebel against a society that deemed sex as an act to procreate, and not enjoy (kind of like the medieval times ) Him to fulfill the basic human need of companionship that was denied by Big Brother.

• How has the past shaped their lives?

I don’t recall Julia’s past, I may have glazed over if they mentioned it during the book. However, Winton’s was mentioned multiple times, and every time he thought back to his youth, I wanted to punch him in the face, repeatedly. He was a spiteful, selfish, arrogant child, who should have been kicked in the shin.

• Do you admire or disapprove of them?

I disapprove of just about every character in this book. Oddly enough, the only character I didn’t despise was the old woman (prole) outside the window who would sing. She reminded me of a grandmother figure, and I’m sure as simple as they assumed proles were, their humanity and compassion were abundant.

• Do they remind you of people you know?

I suppose the old woman reminded me of Gram, but other than that, no. Is it bad to think that even though they are regarded as sub-human, they had better lives than those in the Party? Would you rather live as a blind sheep who goes through life with no worries, or someone who knows what’s happening on the outside of the sheep pen, but can’t do anything about it except live though it? Knowing that your life is nothing more than a tool used by the government?

3. Do the main characters change by the end of the book? Do they grow or mature? Do they learn something about themselves and how the world works?

I don’t think they grow in anyway. I think by the end of the book they both learn just how truly selfish they really are. They care about no one but themselves.

4. Is the plot engaging—does the story interest you? Is this a plot-driven book: a fast-paced page-turner? Or does the story unfold slowly with a focus on character development? Were you surprised by the plot's complications? Or did you find it predictable, even formulaic?

The story itself is very interesting. The delivery, not so much. I didn’t find the book to be fast-paced. I found it to be slow, and tedious. I didn’t find the book to be completely predictable, because honestly, I was hoping for some redemption of Winston’s selfishness with some act that changed some portion (even if it was just a small wave) in Big Brother. I felt cheated.

5. Talk about the book's structure. Is it a continuous story...or interlocking short stories? Does the time-line move forward chronologically...or back and forth between past and present? Does the author use a single viewpoint or shifting viewpoints? Why might the author have chosen to tell the story the way he or she did—and what difference does it make in the way you read or understand it?

Thankfully, there were no shifting view points on narration, because honestly, those really piss me off. There were quite a few times where we were shown a glimpse of the past, but mostly, it moved forward. Personally, I prefer single viewpoints in a story. I find multiple narrators to be an interruption in the way that I read a story, and find that it makes the story choppy.

6. What main ideas—themes—does the author explore? (Consider the title, often a clue to a theme.) Does the author use symbols to reinforce the main ideas? The main idea around this story is government control of everything. Thoughts, actions, etc.

I don’t find that the title is a clue to the theme, merely an indication when this happens? Yes, that was a question. Although, I don’t feel like the story takes place in 1984, probably because that time has come and gone, and it was nothing like described. Granted, I know the book was written in the 40’s, but still. I have always been terrible with symbolism. So, I would have no clue about whether they were being used.

7. What passages strike you as insightful, even profound? Perhaps a bit of dialog that's funny or poignant or that encapsulates a character? Maybe there's a particular comment that states the book's thematic concerns?

There was only one time that I felt the need to highlight a passage, thankfully, on my kindle it gives me the option to do just that. “There are only four ways in which a ruling group can call from power. Either it is conquered from without, or it governs so inefficiently that the masses are stirred to revolt, or it allows a strong and discontented Middle group to come into being, or it loses its own self-confidence and willingness to govern.” This really made me think about how our country is being run. I also keep thinking about the woman outside the window who was always singing to herself, and the time when Winston realizes that she’s beautiful in her own right.

8. Is the ending satisfying? If so, why? If not, why not...and how would you change it?

I hated the ending. I was hoping that in the end Winston would finally be able to “stick it to the man”. Unfortunately, he became what they wanted him to become, a mindless drone who thought and did what he was told. Personally, I would have ended it with him hating Big Brother, just to have the satisfaction of knowing that in the end, your convictions will prevail over all. I don’t want to live in a world where I would sacrifice those I love just to save myself the pain.

9. If you could ask the author a question, what would you ask? Have you read other books by the same author? If so how does this book compare. If not, does this book inspire you to read others?

Did he intend for the book to be a warning? I haven’t read anything else by him, and honestly, I don’t care for his writing style, but I will be reading Animal Farm because it’s on the list. Hopefully, it’s not the same style of writing, because I may poke my eyes out.

10. Has this novel changed you—broadened your perspective? Have you learned something new or been exposed to different ideas about people or a certain part of the world?

I think you may be right when you say that this will be a book I can learn to appreciate. Not the writing, but the ideas. I wonder if all superpowers tend to react the same way when in power. Is ultimate control their desire? Ultimate control of what? People? Thoughts? Ideas? Everything? I didn’t learn anything new, but it does make you think about the world we live in today, and how much of it mimics what we deal with on a daily basis. The lies we are fed from the government, the inability to act certain ways, the grooming of younger generations.