Sunday, August 30, 2009

Religious Prisons?

To find out exactly what religion is, we must first explain its origin. There are two broad groups with theories on the origins of religion. They are faith-based groups, and secular-based groups. Faith based groups believe that there are nineteen major world religions, which can then be further subdivided into over 10,000 distinct factions. Secular based groups (also referred to as science based religions) believe that homosapiens evolved from a species of proto-humans that originated in Africa.

However, it is very difficult to ascertain when the very first religion started. Religion had already been in existence for thousands of years when the art of writing was established. Unfortunately, by that time, the details of the first religion origins had been lost. It has been speculated that the base of the first religion was created as a response to fear. As our society grew, our religions became more organized and focused on fertility.

There are two main types of religion that people of today follow; monotheism and henotheism. Monotheism is a religion where a single male god is worshipped, whereas henotheism recognizes a single main deity, but also recognizes the existence of other idols as well.

Not only is the origin of religion under speculation, but also the way it is defined. Princeton.edu defines religion as, “a strong belief in a supernatural power or powers that control human destiny.” Where Merriam-Webster dictionary defines it as, “the service and worship of God or the supernatural”. The Encyclopedia-Britannica defines religion as, “consisting of a person’s relation to God or to gods or spirits”. Finally, the American Heritage Dictionary defines it as: “belief in and reverence for a supernatural power or powers regarded as creator and governor of the universe.” Although that is not a comprehensive list of all the definitions of religion, it does give a general feel for the inconsistencies associated with the term.

In 1987, the United States Supreme Court ruled in Turner v. Safley, 482 U.S. 78, 84 that “prison walls do not form a barrier separating prison inmates from the protections of the Constitution” which opened the doorway to uphold freedom of religion for prisoners. Another landmark for religion in prison happened in 2000 when the federal statute Religious Land Use and Institutionalized Persons Act (RLUIPA) was passed.

This statute was passed in order to “provide stronger protection for religious freedom in the land-use and prison contexts”. While the RLUIPA statue protects religion, it is still left up to the courts to decide what beliefs constitute an actual religion. Unfortunately, these decisions are quite often in conflict.

Even though one of our basic human rights is freedom of religion, where do we draw the line when it comes to someone who has already had their rights stripped from them? When asked what the meaning of religion in prison is, an inmate in a maximum security prison responded with, “When you are stripped of your freedom, your job, your family, you begin to seek your purpose in life, and through that you find someone greater than yourself, God.” It’s a very profound statement and certainly one that is cause for deeper research on the matter.

While this statute and court case allow most religious prisoners an emotional outlet, it does not always include those who belong to a minority religious group (For example; Wicca, Satanism, etc). While I don’t believe any specific religion should receive special attention, I do believe that if one person is allowed to practice their belief, than everyone should be able to. Sometimes, due to sheer boredom, some inmates will create “religions” to gain legal protection for activities that are not normally allowed. Naturally, these religions are not protected under the law. While there are some inmates who fabricate their religions, those who belong to a non-traditional religion and are sincere in their belief should not be denied their faith.

Fortunately, there is a stipulation that must be followed to help keep these lawsuits under control. “A prisoner who has had three or more frivolous cases dismissed is no longer permitted to file federal lawsuits concerning prison conditions unless he is in imminent danger of serious physical injury.” An excellent example of one of those frivolous lawsuits is when a “religion invented by an inmate in which a meal of steak and wine was claimed to be a sacrament. The federal courts had little difficulty in identifying the sham and denying the prisoner’s claims”.

Another example of prisoner’s taking advantage is when they create the facade of a religion used in an effort to justify tax fraud. “Typically, in these cases an individual (sometimes after buying ordination and a church charter by mail) would set up a bank account in the name of the one-person church, deposit all of his money in the church’s account (claiming a tax deduction for the contribution), and use that account to pay all of his living expenses.” It is obvious that some inmates are not sincere in their religious beliefs, and unfortunately, it paints an awful picture for those who actually are.

In Cutter v. Wilkinson, No. 03-9877 the “plaintiffs in this case are Ohio prisoners who contend that various Ohio corrections officials have violated the Religious Land Use and Institutionalized Persons Act (RLUIPA) by refusing to accommodate the prisoners' religious beliefs and practices. In response, the prison officials challenged the constitutionality of RLUIPA, alleging, among other claims, that the act improperly advanced religion in violation of the Establishment Clause of the First Amendment. The district court, adopting the recommendations of the magistrate judge, denied the prison officials' motion to dismiss. The United States Court of Appeals for the Sixth Circuit reversed, holding that RLUIPA violated the Establishment Clause. The effect of the statute is to elevate the level of judicial review of restrictions imposed by prison officials on religious practice.”

While it is true that the religions listed in this case are of the non-traditional type, that does not mean they are not religions. According to data from the Federal Bureau of Prisons, in 1997 the top two traditional religions listed were: Catholics made up 31% of the prison population, and Protestants made up 28% of the population.

Another fact that I found interesting was that the third highest percentage of religions documented were listed as None/Atheist/Unknown. I don’t believe that listing those three categories together gives an accurate representation of non-traditional religions, such as earth based religions and other obscure religions which were not listed on the Federal Bureau of Prisons data collection at all.

People “find” religion for many different reasons in life. Sometimes it is when a loved one dies, or some other milestone in their life. Other times it’s the last thing they have to cling to, for example, serving time in prison. Inmates look to religion while they are in prison for several different reasons. Some of them hope to gain a sense of direction or enlightenment and “purpose in their lives, peace of mind, a safe haven from the rest of the prison population, to meet other inmates with similar interests, have access to prison resources or special privileges, or to influence parole considerations. Because of the last reason, prisoners involved in religious activities are frequently met with skepticism or distrust from prison staff and other inmates.”

Due to mistrust of prisoners, many people believe that numerous inmates are simply using religion as an excuse to help them gain early parole. There have been several instances where former inmates who were active in religious activities while in prison committed offenses after their release from prison which added further support to these negative feelings. However, some studies have shown that the more active an inmate involves themselves in religious activities in prison, the less likely they will be a repeat offender after their release from prison.

When someone is convicted and sentenced to prison, they are stripped of all their basic rights and freedoms as payment for their crimes against society, whatever they may be. Although these sentences are justifiable, we must also maintain a balance between punishment and cruel and unusual punishment. Since prisoners have so little in prison, religious study becomes a large portion of their lives there, and becomes one of the few things that can give their time meaning.

There are also differences in “opinions about prisoners' rights often stem from differing ideologies about the purpose of the penal system. Those who support tough prison policies say the primary goal of incarceration should be to punish wrongdoers and deter future crime. To meet that goal, they say, prisoners should enjoy few privileges, work hard and face harsh retribution if they disobey the rules.”

They believe that prisons should be more worried about rehabilitating the inmates so that they are able to turn their lives around. “They typically support social programs, counseling, education and vocational training for inmates, especially for those who will someday be released to society.”

There are also many who believe that “criminals, especially those who commit the most violent and remorseless crimes, should not be given the compassion that they failed to offer to their victims. Prison will not serve as a deterrent if it is a pleasant place to live or if criminals are provided amenities such as weightlifting equipment and free education.” They believe that harsher prison conditions help reduction crime. They also say that unpleasant prison conditions and restricted privileges “has kept former inmates from committing further crimes and deterred others from heading down the path to prison.”

However, there have also been supporters of prisoners' rights who say that tougher prison policies lead to inhumane treatment of the inmates, which can reduce the likelihood of reforming them. “They say that even the most brutal of criminals have the right to be treated humanely within prison walls.”

While I do not follow what most people consider a “traditional” religion, I do feel that it’s important that those who wish to be active in their faith, whatever it may be, should have that opportunity. However, I do not believe that they should be given special treatment to do it. While many religions require different supplies and unique circumstances, I feel that the prison system should be able to deem what is reasonable and what is not, providing that they include ALL known religions, whether they are traditional or not.

I do understand that some inmates are going to take advantage of the system whenever they are given the opportunity, and unfortunately, they ruin it for those who are sincere and actually wish to follow their faith as close as it was meant to be as possible.

I think that Cutter v. Wilkinson, No. 03-9877, was a step in the right direction for all religious beliefs within the prison system. While I am not naïve enough to believe that there will be religious harmony within the prison system (we don’t even have religious harmony amongst ourselves) I do feel that we are making progress in the right direction.

There is so much hate and prejudice in the world that it is only natural for it to make its way into the prison system. As human beings we are flawed by nature and tend to recoil from what we don’t know, or don’t understand.

0 comments: